The Plot Twist Gamble

Nothing like a sudden turn of the wheel that leaves the audience in disbelief. But what happens when the audience actually disbelieves? Screenwriters are aware of the double edged sword quality of plot twists: they can make a story successful almost by themselves, but can also turn against it if they come off as predictable or implausible.

In some genres (horror, thriller) they have become an expected, almost mandatory device. Robert Wiene’s The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari (1920) set the foundations for the use of narrative unreliability in films. And it’s already a great example of a twist that didn’t only aim for shock- it also tried to provide a solid justification for the visual and narrative styles of the film.

Night Shyamalan’s irregular career illustrates both the rewards and the risks of subjecting the story to a plot twist. The recent success of Split may have brought him to a second youth, but for many years, the ‘Shyamalan twists” served more as a burden than a perk, becoming the smoking gun that proves and defines the film’s failure.

So what makes a good plot twist? If Aristotle stated that good art should be both unexpected and inevitable, contemporary screenwriters like William Goldman have pinpointed a reality that Hollywood has exploited well: that a controversial ending may still work effectively if it’s at least satisfying.

Some examples of films with memorable plot twists are:

(1941) The Maltese Falcon

(1958) Vertigo

(1960) Psycho

(1968) Planet of the Apes

(1973) The Sting

(1973) Soylent Green

(1973) The Wicker Man

(1980) The Empire Strikes Back

(1987) Angel Heart

(1992) The Crying Game

(1995) The Usual Suspects

(1995) 12 Monkeys

(1996) Primal Fear

(1999) The Sixth Sense

(1999) Fight Club

(2000) Memento

(2004) Saw

(2006) The Prestige

(2016) Arrival

Edge of Tomorrow Script

Edge of Tomorrow poster thumbnail
Year:2014
Director:Doug Liman
Written by:Jez Butterworth (Screenplay), Christopher McQuarrie (Screenplay), John-Henry Butterworth (Screenplay), Hiroshi Sakurazaka (Novel)

Script Synopsis:Major Bill Cage is an officer who has never seen a day of combat when he is unceremoniously demoted and dropped into combat. Cage is killed within minutes, managing to take an alpha alien down with him. He awakens back at the beginning of the same day and is forced to fight and die again... and again - as physical contact with the alien has thrown him into a time loop.
*11827

Jack Reacher Script

Jack Reacher poster thumbnail
Year:2012
Director:Christopher McQuarrie
Written by:Lee Child (Novel), Christopher McQuarrie (Screenplay)

Script Synopsis:When a gunman takes five lives with six shots, all evidence points to the suspect in custody. On interrogation, the suspect offers up a single note: "Get Jack Reacher!" So begins an extraordinary chase for the truth, pitting Jack Reacher against an unexpected enemy, with a skill for violence and a secret to keep.
11161

Jack The Giant Slayer Script

Jack The Giant Slayer poster thumbnail
Year:2013
Director:Bryan Singer
Written by:Darren Lemke (Screenplay), Christopher McQuarrie (Screenplay), Dan Studney (Screenplay), Darren Lemke (Story), David Dobkin (Story)

Script Synopsis:The story of an ancient war that is reignited when a young farmhand unwittingly opens a gateway between our world and a fearsome race of giants. Unleashed on the Earth for the first time in centuries, the giants strive to reclaim the land they once lost, forcing the young man, Jack into the battle of his life to stop them. Fighting for a kingdom, its people, and the love of a brave princess, he comes face to face with the unstoppable warriors he thought only existed in legend–and gets the chance to become a legend himself.
10477

The Way of the Gun

The Way of the Gun poster thumbnail
Year:2000
Director:Christopher McQuarrie

Script Synopsis:Two criminal drifters without sympathy get more than they bargained for after kidnapping and holding for ransom the surrogate mother of a powerful and shady man.
5376

The Usual Suspects

The Usual Suspects poster thumbnail
Year:1995
Director:Bryan Singer
Written by:Christopher McQuarrie (Screenplay)

Script Synopsis:Held in an L.A. interrogation room, Verbal Kint attempts to convince the feds that a mythic crime lord, Keyser Soze, not only exists, but was also responsible for drawing him and his four partners into a multi-million dollar heist that ended with an explosion in San Pedro harbor – leaving few survivors. Verbal lures his interrogators with an incredible story of the crime lord's almost supernatural prowess.
*5152

The Tourist

The Tourist poster thumbnail
Year:2010
Director:Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck
Written by:Florian Henckel von Donnersmarck (Screenplay), Julian Fellowes (Screenplay), Jérôme Salle (Original Story), Christopher McQuarrie (Screenplay)

Script Synopsis:American tourist Frank meets mysterious British woman Elsie on the train to Venice. Romance seems to bud, but there's more to her than meets the eye. Remake of the 2005 French film "Anthony Zimmer", written and directed by Jérôme Salle.
*4898

Valkyrie

Valkyrie poster thumbnail
Year:2008
Director:Bryan Singer
Written by:Christopher McQuarrie (Screenplay), Nathan Alexander (Screenplay)

Script Synopsis:Wounded in Africa during World War II, Nazi Col. Claus von Stauffenberg returns to his native Germany and joins the Resistance in a daring plan to create a shadow government and assassinate Adolf Hitler. When events unfold so that he becomes a central player, he finds himself tasked with both leading the coup and personally killing the Führer.
*4710